The case for weakness
Remember the times in shooters when you’re holding on to dear
life with your last 3 HP of health? Remember when you’d have to carefully play,
dodging and firing like a crazed jackrabbit? Of course you do. It’s possibly
the most visceral moment of gunplay, where even though you know you have the capability to quit and try
again, you share the fear and hope of survival of the character.
But imagine the same situation with regenerating health. Duck
behind cover, wait for the jam to fall off your eyes, and attack. Rinse,
repeat. At this point, it doesn’t even matter whether or not you lose half your
health trying to down one enemy, you can get that health back in seconds.
Adding regenerating health to a shooter, to me, reeks of lazy
design. There is no need for the designers of the game to come up with
different scenarios, so every battleground is a long chamber or corridor
spattered with chest high walls, as if for a psychotic athlete. An enemy coming
at you while you shoot it is a situation impossible in a regenerating health
shooter, if only because you feel naked without your back superglued to
concrete.
In trying to make playing the game easier, the games have
instead become easier to develop. Since every player has a virtually unlimited
reserve of health, difficulty scaling is not an issue. Why do that much work,
when you can simply give the enemies more and more health and keep adding one
more to each successive battle? Give the player a bit less health, and it’ll be
fair game. By the later stages of the
game if the challenge put before you is to kill two boomers together, each
needing a magazine and a half of bullets or two blasts from a goddamn space laser, and equipped with
grenade launchers, there’s something wrong with the difficulty curve.
| Especially when it looks like this |
If, at a point in a shooter with hit points, there are less
enemies in a battle than the previous one, then that means that testing has determined
that players have less than optimal health at that point, so the designers are
forced to compensate and innovate. If you’ve heard any of Valve’s developer
commentaries, they almost spend as much time testing a game as they do
releasing it. This means that scenarios are tuned in such a way that with the
skill a player can be expected to have developed over the course of the game
can get through them with a sense of challenge, but not an unfair one. In a
regen shooter, there is no need to start the player out in a place where it
would be easy to snipe two or three enemies before the rest attack you; there’s
no need to add a small cubbyhole to throw a grenade through to flush out the
opposition. Which is why most fights appear to be copy-pasted.
Now, since even the worst player can be expected to have full
health before every action segment, the regular challenge won’t do, because
that would mean that the player could brush off the damage easily. This is
where one-hit-KO enemies come in. These can take form of the Juggernauts of
Modern Warfare 2, the Berserkers in Gears, or insert-overpowered-enemy from
Generic-FPS/TPS . Not only does this make the situations with these enemies
frustrating instead of challenging, it feels like the game is cheating. The
most powerful non-boss enemies in Half Life 2 are the Snipers, and they can
take off a third of your health in a shot. To defeat them, you have to use
cover and get below their vantage point,
and lob a grenade, with the game trying to warrant a use for Freeman’s physics
degree.
This example differs from the berserker in that the challenge
offered does not require reflexes, it requires understanding attack patterns
and exploiting weaknesses that the character has. Extreme specifics that are
designed only so that the enemy can be more difficult, whether it is due to
tiny hitboxes or insane timing, are just a quick copout of offering some real
difficulty.
The problem is witnessed in even sharper relief when playing
faster paced games like Quake 3 Arena.
In the multiplayer, it is always beneficial to shoot at an opponent,
whether or not you have the necessary firepower for a frag. If their health is
lowered, they are more likely to rush to a health pickup, making it easier to
set up an ambush. Later encounters with the enemy become easier when you have
the upper hand. When you’re playing
Gears multiplayer, unless you’re all using shotguns, or are chainsaw fanatics,
there really is no reason to get out of cover, so much of the round is spent
staring at the places where your enemy disappeared, and hoping he ducks out
long enough to shoot, essentially making it a game of Whack-a-mole with added
gore.
Health systems themselves are quite stupid, seeing as the
only way out of being shot is quick surgery, possible amputation and months of
rehabilitation, and even if your enemy just stands there for eons, (which
wouldn’t surprise me, given today’s AI), the thought of that system has to be
too much for even the most masochistic gamer out there. So we have to make do
with magical food that’s full of nutritional goodness, injections that have to be bad for you in the long run,
or bullets popping out of your skin every time you flex.
More realistic systems have been tried in games like Deus Ex,
where if your arm has been extensively damaged, you can’t use two handed
weapons anymore. Other examples of hyper realism have been seen in the original
turn based Fallout, where you can individually target any part of the
opponent’s body, each for a different effect. These systems are few and far in
between, at least in part because the definition for hardcore is very different
for today’s world. In older games, the protagonists were actually weak. Mario
has one HP, and at most two if you have a mushroom, and with no save system to
speak of the console would be turned on for hours, while you try not to throw
your lives away because of a mistimed jump. Die enough, and you have to start
again from the beginning. Now I don’t suggest that games go back to permadeath,
since that helps no one, but at least a little bit of that design sensibility
could be bottled and put to great use.
However, say what you will, the systems fit the world. When
you’re contolling a behemoth of a man who is like Chuck Norris crossed with a
prick, realism is already in tatters, and if you shoot the corpse a few more
times,
then at least you can frame a photo and sell it as a Giger.
| Along with the other stuff in the game |
The amount of testosterone flowing out of the screen is
almost to the point of self parody, and I hope that it is, because any game
character unironically saying “More like ten shitloads” should be summarily
shot. Not like it’d hurt him much, anyway.
| Like this, but manlier |
No comments:
Post a Comment